Eq: Real Estate
In recent weeks, REITs like other rate-sensitive sectors have been pummeled as long-term yields have surged higher due to the resilience of inflation, a hawkish Fed, and expectations of substantial Treasury supply hitting the market later this year.
But some contrarians are pointing out that there have been some positive developments for the sector on a long-term basis. First, most of the damage for the sector has come from high rates as earnings have continued to hold steady. This has led to valuations becoming quite attractive.
Additionally while the timing of the Fed’s pivot is unknown, it’s certainly close to the end of its hiking cycle. And just as the start of the hiking cycle led to steep losses for REITs, it’s likely that the start of rate cuts will send shares soaring higher.
Finally, it’s also interesting to note that at the start of the rate hike cycle, the sector was extremely correlated to Treasuries. But this relationship has considerably loosened and has led to a bullish divergence.
Remarkably, the broad-based Schwab US REIT ETF has been making higher lows, while Treasury yields have been making higher highs. This is an indication of demand and that institutions are using the weakness to accumulate shares.
Finsum: REITs are not making lower lows despite the breakout in Treasury yields. Some contrarians see this as a bullish signal from the market.
REIT stocks are slightly down YTD. On the bright side, yields are at their highest level in decades, defaults have not materially risen and occupancy rates have been stable. However, this has not been substantial enough to offset the headwind from rising rates.
This headwind is only getting more potent with yields on longer-term Treasuries breaking out to new highs which is bearish for the asset class given its embedded leverage and exposure to rates. Higher rates also are impacting demand and leading to lower affordability.
The most damage is evident in commercial real estate, where REITs are trading close to their lows while REITs with exposure to healthcare, industrial, or residential sectors are performing much better. This is mostly a reflection of a structural change following the pandemic as companies cut back on office space.
In the event that rates remain at these lofty levels, REIT stocks are likely to underperform. However, the current weakness in the sector could present a long-term opportunity to accumulate REITs that continue to grow their earnings and use the weakness in the sector to add high-quality holdings at attractive prices.
Finsum: REITs are moving lower as Treasury yields break out to new highs. While higher yields are a major headwind, the current selloff is likely to create some attractive opportunities.
This market cycle has been unique for a variety of reasons and constantly caught investors on the wrong-footed. Another unique aspect of the current market is the strong performance of private real estate while public real estate has languished.
For Advisor Perspectives, Carlin Calcaterra and Brendan McCurdy of Ares Wealth Management Solutions investigate whether this is presenting an opportunity to buy the dip in public real estate or if this is a harbinger of weakness for private real estate.
They use historical data as a guide and acknowledge that public real estate has delivered higher returns over the long-term. But, this is primarily due to higher amounts of leverage with public real estate. Adjusting for this factor, they believe that private real estate is the better investment from a risk/reward perspective.
They also believe that the data indicates low levels of correlation between public and private real estate. Therefore, these instances of divergence are not unusual and not necessarily predictive.
In fact, 2 ⁄ 3 of the time that public real estate had more than a double-digit drawdown, there was no subsequent drawdown in private real estate. When there was a drawdown in private real estate, it often came at a nine to twelve month lag. This is notable given that the drawdown in public real estate began more than 18 months ago, and the asset class has been recovering in recent months.
Finsum: A major market mystery is the significant weakness in public real estate while private real estate has continued to generate positive returns. Will this outperformance continue or is public real estate a leading indicator for private real estate?
More...
In the Wall Street Journal, Konrad Putzier and Will Parker cover why the next few years for multifamily real estate are likely to be challenging following a strong bull market over the past decade. However, the trends that underpinned this bull market are slowing or reverting in some cases.
These include rising rents, a wide gap between supply and demand, and high rates which is complicating efforts to refinance. Of course these challenges are compounded by the fact that many owners and operators of apartment buildings took on too much debt with the belief that rising rents and property values would overcome any issues of leverage.
However, they didn’t account for the highest rates in decades especially as rates don’t seem likely to come down anytime soon given continued resilience for the economy and labor market. YTD, apartment building values are down 14%, undoing much of last year’s 25% gain.
Already, some apartment owners have defaulted, and many fear that more defaults are imminent. While high rates are the precipitating factor, the woes have also highlighted that many owners had too much leverage. Many borrowed up to 80% of the property’s value using short-term, floating-rate debt. Additionally, credit markets might be tougher to access given the ongoing struggles of regional banks.
Finsum: Typically, apartment buildings are seen as one of the safest parts of the real estate market. This is not currently true given that many owners have too much leverage and are seeing rents moderate while costs continue to climb.
REITs are attracting attention from investors for a variety of reasons. For one, it’s looking increasingly likely that the US will avoid a recession which bodes well for occupancy rates, property values, and home prices. Second, the Fed is in the final stages of its rate hike cycle which means interest rates will go from a strong headwind to a mild tailwind especially if inflation continues to move lower.
Due to weakness over the past year and a half, REITs are quite compelling from a value perspective while also offering juicy yields to investors. For Benzinga, Kevin Vandenboss identifies 2 REITs that investors should consider buying.
He likes SL Green Realty which is an owner and operator of premium Manhattan commercial real estate property. While many areas of commercial real estate like offices and retail may never recover, SL Green is a bet that premium properties will recover - a historically savvy bet. Currently, the stock yields 8.8% and has a stable payout ratio of 59%, indicating a stable dividend.
Another is Medical Properties Trust which focuses on hospital facilities and has properties in 10 different countries, leading to a diversified portfolio. Also, medical facilities tend to be much more stable than residential or commercial real estate especially given an aging population in most parts of the world. Finally, it also has a dividend yield of 11% and a track record of annual dividend increases.
Finsum: While REITs have been an underperformer for much of the past couple of years, the sector offers juicy yields and tantalizing upside given recent macro developments.
One of the most puzzling developments over the past 18 months is the wide gap between public and private real estate. Many publicly traded REITs are down between 30% and 40% from their highs in 2021, while private real estate funds are flat or have losses in the single-digits.
There are a variety of theories to account for this disconnect, including expectations of mounting losses in commercial real estate (CRE) given that office occupancy rates are not returning to pre-pandemic levels. However, it’s also fair to note that in recent months publicly traded REITs have outperformed and somewhat shrunk the gap. In Institutional Investor, Hannah Zang covers why many investors are seeing an opportunity in REITs and believe that the market is overreacting to weakness in CRE especially given that it only accounts for 3% of the total REIT market.
Currently, the cap rate for REITs is 50 basis points higher than private real estate. Historically, this has indicated a buying opportunity in the sector especially as some of the macro headwinds of the sector seem to be dissipating with the vast majority of real estate prices holding steady and the Fed in the final innings of its rate hike cycle.
Finsum: There’s an interesting divergence between private and public real estate. However, many investors see opportunity in publicly traded REITs and believe that investors have overreacted to macro and CRE issues.