Displaying items by tag: smart beta

(New York)

ETFs are a product that has been growing at breakneck speed. AUM in the product is approaching $4 tn, which is astonishing given that it has really only taken a decade to get there, but still quite a bit smaller than the $16 tn in mutual funds. Experts say that the ETF market is going to increasingly resemble the mutual fund market as offerings diversify into smart beta, thematic ETFs, customizable ETFs, and fixed income. The last area—fixed income—is where creative indexing makes the most sense, as doing so can account for the common weighting issues that are much riskier in bonds than in equities (you don’t want your largest holding to be the issuer with the most debt).

FINSUM: The logic for fixed income ETFs is very strong, especially given how illiquid and restrictive buying bonds directly is. However, smart beta and other active ETFs (which are more expensive) don’t really have a big leg up on experienced mutual funds.

(New York)

One of the pioneers of smart beta investing has just gone on the record tearing down the concept. A long time quant strategist, Vincent Deluard, who helped build early smart beta funds, has lost faith in the strategy as he has seen fund providers use statistics to disingenuously prove all manner of strategies using selective back-testing. Deluard even built model portfolios to show how “dumb” constructions could lead to good results, and “smart” constructions could lead to poor results.

FINSUM: We don’t think smart beta is necessarily “smart” or “dumb”. In the end, these are really just strategies that are only as “good” as the market circumstances they are applied to. Smart and dumb is ultimately about the buyer of the funds.

(New York)

Advisors considering putting client capital into smart beta funds need to be prepared for what to expect. The reality is that smart beta strategies tend to accentuate the returns of the market, or run counter to them altogether. In up times a smart beta strategy playing into the market’s strengths can do much better than the index overall, the opposite can happen in down markets. However, even in decent markets, many smart beta strategies can perform terribly because of the nature of the rise.

FINSUM: If you are just getting into smart beta funds, it is really important that you understand the strategy inside and out to make sure you understand how it will sit within your portfolio.

(New York)

Despite the rally, stocks are still down 5% from the January peak. But Invesco, it is down around 15%, which Barron’s argues presents a great buying opportunity. Invesco’s mutual fund business will earn less income if stocks fall, but unlike others, it may be a big beneficiary of the next bear market. Two reasons for this include Invesco having a strong balance sheet to make low-priced acquisitions when times are tough (as it did during the Crisis) and the fact that it has a great smart beta business, which should do well in tough times. The stock currently trades at a 44% discount to BlackRock on an earnings multiple basis, making the price attractive.

FINSUM: Invesco seems like it would be good to use in a pair trade in a down turn as its relative performance should be better than competitors.